So, I’ve been thinking about how races work through the
various editions, and I came to the realisation I much prefer having race/class
as a combination rather than being the same thing mechanically.
On top of this, I also felt that flat bonuses to stats were
kinda boring and deterministic, so instead I made a system whereby you just
have a different spread of values for your stats, generated by rolling dice
other than 3d6. So, substitute the usual stat bonuses for the rolls below. Other
abilities for races should probably be left as – is. The only issue is how to
make humans operate on-par with the demihumans – possibly give them the ability
to switch two stats? (Assuming hard rolling down-the-line)
This table should work for any system of D&D, and could
be tweaked to other systems.
Statistic
|
Human
|
Elf
|
Dwarf
|
Halfling
|
Orc
|
Charisma
|
3d6
|
2d6 + 1d8
|
2d6 + 1d4
|
3d6
|
1d6 + 2d4
|
Constitution
|
3d6
|
3d4
|
1d6 + 2d8
|
2d6 + 1d4
|
1d6 + 2d8
|
Dexterity
|
3d6
|
1d6 + 2d8
|
1d6 + 2d4
|
3d8
|
3d6
|
Intelligence
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
1d6 + 2d4
|
Strength
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
2d6 + 1d8
|
1d6 + 2d4
|
3d8
|
Wisdom
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
3d6
|
The above rolls use human as a baseline, Elves as graceful,
charming but fragile, Dwarves as strong, tough but dour and clumsy, Halflings
as nimble yet weak and fragile and Orcs as powerful physically but stunted in
other areas.
So, using the above table, we get the following spread of
statistics amongst the average
members of that race.
Statistic
|
Human
|
Elf
|
Dwarf
|
Halfling
|
Orc
|
Charisma
|
7-12
|
9-15
|
7-11
|
7-12
|
7-11
|
Constitution
|
7-12
|
5-9
|
8-16
|
7-11
|
8-16
|
Dexterity
|
7-12
|
8-16
|
6-10
|
9-17
|
7-12
|
Intelligence
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
6-10
|
Strength
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
9-15
|
6-10
|
9-17
|
Wisdom
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
7-12
|
Whereas this table shows the maximum possible rolled stat for any of these races, with a minimum
of 3 for any of them.
Statistic
|
Human
|
Elf
|
Dwarf
|
Halfling
|
Orc
|
Charisma
|
18
|
20
|
16
|
18
|
14
|
Constitution
|
18
|
12
|
22
|
16
|
22
|
Dexterity
|
18
|
22
|
14
|
24
|
18
|
Intelligence
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
14
|
Strength
|
18
|
18
|
20
|
14
|
24
|
Wisdom
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Runequest style!
ReplyDelete